Welcome Guest Login or Signup
FEATURED MEMBERS | BIRTHDAYS | LIVE CHAT | BOOKMARK
| LANGUAGE:
 

Mondayb
PROFILE   GALLERY   BLOGS   GUESTBOOK   FRIENDS   FAVORITES   VIDEOS  
 


RSS
Jury service
Posted On: 02/25/2010 07:45:00
Recently a friend was called up for jury service and he was asking people for their experiences. I have listed mine below. He was looking forward to a week or two off work but things have not gone well for him. He has a complicated murder trial involving six people and has been told to expect the trial to go on till late April This is week one.
 
Have you ever been called up to serve on a jury?
My first experience turned out to be very disappointing. Because the area that I lived in had no crown court I found that I had to go to the Central Criminal Court. That's the Old Bailey. I had visions of a massive case although I did not fancy anything too long. Sadly it was not to be. I was with a reserve group of 20 who just hung about outside different courts in case someone decided at the last minute to change their plea to not guilty. We did this for two weeks, going home every day around 11:00.
 
The second occasion was a bit more dramatic. We had four stints in court on different cases. None were that big but it was a good experience.
 
Many years later a local court was built and I had another two week stint (Stretch?) there. This time three cases. One thing I was glad about was not having any of the nasty trials where jurors have to view heart rending pictures!
 
From my experience of juries I am glad that I have never stood in the dock. Listening to others I could not believe the prejudice that was put out. Racial prejudice was perhaps the main one but there were so many others. One lady was convinced that the person in the dock must have been drunk because he was Irish and all Irish are drunks.  Perhaps the worst were a few who believed in woo. Is he guilty because my horoscope says so?? Was he really putting out evil vibes that a lady claimed she could pick up? Can someone LOOK guilty? Can someone really be guilty because you don't like the look of him? Or her? There is an old idea about not trusting someone whose eyes are too close together. No one said that but I bet it was in someone's mind. And recently I heard of a trial being abandoned because a juror had looked on the internet and found out that the defendant had been on trial before on similar charges. So he must be guilty. Not everyone takes the whole thing seriously. Some will vote with the majority just to get home in time for dinner! There have been cases reported in the newspapers of jurors being caught listening to an MP3 player while the trial was on and one playing games on a hand held computer.
Strangely I had three call ups and my wife never had one.
 
I wonder. Has anyone else had odd experiences doing jury service?


Bookmark:



Viewing 1 - 7 out of 7 Comments

02/26/2010 06:45:21

Thanks for that Rosy. I am glad that I am not the only one to meet the wrong people.


An addition that you have reminded me of. A juror avoiding giving a verdict on a Friday afternoon because the jury had been warned that they would have to spend the weekend in an hotel if they did not deliver. And this juror fancied the idea.


We never got taken out to lunch or were provided with sandwiches. I am not sure if I have this exactly right but I think we got what was called a "subsistence allowance" for food. It was enough for a good pub lunch and a pint. I realised then why there are so many pubs around the Old Bailey



02/25/2010 20:51:49

Yes, I have served on a jury.   The case was "assaulting a police officer".   It was an open and shut case for 11 members of the jury, going on the evidence presented.   But one of the jurors (a young, cocky and very rude male had a thing against the police and said he would never agree to "guilty" because of his hatred of the police.   So, six days of wasted time and money as we had to advise the judge that we could not reach a unanimous verdict.   The judge was not happy.  

Just as an aside, we had a special room for our deliberations and where lunch was served - basics like sandwiches and juice. (I can't believe jurors in other countries get taken out to lunch and can have alcohol!).   The fellow who didn't like the police put his feet up on the lunch table on one occasion (while we were eating) and had to be told off by one of the older guys.   He also got into trouble for taking a spray can of deodorant into the jurors' area in the actual court - !!! Hope I never run into him again.

This experience put me off attending again, but I have not been called since.  

Recently, there's been a big trial in Sydney which lasted eleven months (terrorism charges) - they got a week off over Christmas.    I'm so glad I wasn't on that one.

Rosy.



02/25/2010 11:42:07

 I hate that, I'll get out of it if possible. They called me for a murder trial once. I had known this man all my life but guess I didn't  know him at all because he killed his wife.  I got out of that one because I very truthfully told them I don't believe in capital punishment.



02/25/2010 11:24:14

Hi Olegeezer,


Getting home early to have a clean shirt? I can imagine that very easily.


I have to admit that I started out feeling a little self-important and finished rather disillusioned



02/25/2010 11:11:22

I've only been called up once, and it was a non-event. They called far more people than were needed, a few were dismissed, but they still had their 12 before it got to my turn, on each of the three days. So no, I have not served on a jury.



02/25/2010 10:43:19

I've served on several juries.  At one trial the sheriffs deputies escorted us(the jury) to lunch and kept us separate from the rest of the patrons in the restaurant, even escorted us to the loo!

At another trial, when we the jury were deciding the case, one lady juror said she would vote either yes or no because she wanted to get home quickly to make sure her husband had a clean shirt for work!  The defendants guilt or innocents was not on her mind.

I've been excused from two trials because of prejudice (medical mal-practice and product liability)

I can't say my jury experiences were pleasent, but I felt I was performing a duty to my community, a duty, people in many other countries are denied.

Blessings to all,

olegeezer








02/25/2010 09:58:33
Hi Starrylane.

I can see your point about someone falling asleep during an important trial. We were advised not to eat a heavy lunch and to avoid alcohol. Never the less I have to admit that my mind wandered a few times. But my experience of UK courts would make me say that it would be difficult to nod off on the hard benches.

I found myself listening to voices and trying to guess what part of the country they came from. And the harder I tried not to the more I did it!



Smileycons  -  FolderMagic  -  CalendarPal  -  Cloudeight Stationery  -   NotOverTheHill Powered by M3Server.com